Author: Rabbi Schell

  • Parashat Re’eh: We should preoccupy ourselves with what is right in front of us

    Rabbi SchellOur Torah reading for this week is found in the middle section of Moses’ parting sermons to the Israelites before his death and their entry into Canaan.  In the opening readings of the Book of Deuteronomy, Moses has concerned himself with a fundamental review of the journey to the Promised Land. His sermons are filled with criticism of the disloyalty the People displayed to God throughout their journey through the Sinai wilderness, and the many times Moses had to plead with God not to destroy them because of their lack of trust in Him and their tardiness in demonstrating their commitment to embrace His commands. When we arrive at the opening verse of our parashat Re’eh, behold or look, it appears that Moses is pausing before continuing his discourse to the people. He presents himself as God’s messenger and says: “Behold I place before you blessing and curse.”There is a special significance in Moses’ turning from reflection on the people’s past to the present generation of the people standing in front of him.  “Look” he tells the People of Israel: “you do not need to look to the past to find out what your responsibility is.  It is placed here right in front of you!  It is down to each of us today to prevent the society we are part of sliding into becoming accursed; it is down to each of us today to turn it instead into a source of blessing.”Our parashah, is read in the slow build up to the Yamim Nora’im, the High Holidays with the New Year and the Day of Atonement, during the concluding weeks of the Jewish year.  There is a parallel between the People of Israel preparing for their entry to a new, enticing land with hope but also anxiety about what to expect, and our own annual preparation for the arrival of the New Year with a mixture of hope and uncertainty about what that New Year might bring.What parashat Re’eh teaches is possibly the most important perception we take with us into the Yamim Nora’im.  The best that we can bring into our Rosh Hashanah services and prayers is not to dwell on what shaped the year now ending, nor on what the future might bring.   Rather, we should preoccupy ourselves with what is “right in front of us”. We should focus on what we personally can achieve today in “turning into blessing” the life we share with our loved ones, family, friends, colleagues, fellow Jews, and all humanity.This coming Saturday and Sunday is the beginning of the last month of the current Jewish year 5775. May it be a good month for us, may it be a month that brings us closer, closer to our community and to God.– Rabbi Adrian M Schell (Source: Fields, Parashat Re’eh)Torah Reading for Shabbat Re’eh – Rosh Chodesh ElulDeuteronomy 11.26 – 16:17 (Reading: 15:19-16:17 – Plaut p.1272; Hertz p.814)Haftarah: Isaiah 54:11-55:5 (Plaut 1290; Hertz p.818)The Torah Study Breakfast Shiur with Rabbi Schell continues on Shabbat, 29 August at 08.45.Podcast of Rabbi Schell’s weekly Radio Sermons on Radio Today, follow http://betdavid.podomatic.com/.

  • Wonderful Women

    Picture: Estee Stern, Adina Roth, Rabbi Margolis, Marlene Bethlehem, Gila Joffee and Hila Timor AshurTuesday night I was invited as a panel guest speaker at a “Wonderful Women” event, held at Great Park Shul.The objective of the event was to screen the movie “Wonderful Women” and then host a panel discussion regarding the importance of dialogue in breaking down barriers. The documentary, which was screened on Israeli national TV (Channel 1) on Tisha B’ Av last year, illustrates the complex connections between eight secular women from Mateh Yehuda and eight Haredi women from Beit Shemesh (South Africa’s partnership region).  In the film these women come together to represent the meaning of “being a Jewish Woman,” and demonstrate that barriers can be broken down in almost any situation.This evening was organised by P2G, which is a Jewish Agency program connecting some 550 Jewish communities in the Diaspora with 45 Israel Partnership areas. It is dedicated to establishing bridges of understanding between Israeli and Diaspora Jewry. This was the ideal opportunity for communities abroad to become personally involved in developing Israel’s National priority areas. South Africa is partnered with the town of Beit Shemesh and the surrounding rural area of Mateh Yehuda. Our partnership helps the region deal with its changing education and welfare needs, supports the economic development and facilitates a wide range of relationship-building activities.The panel discussion comprised of four women from South Africa (Rebetizzin Estee Stern from Sydenham shul, Adina Roth, myself and Marlene Bethlehem.) From Israel we were privileged to have the producers of the movie- Hila Timor –Ashur and Gila Joffee. We discussed the subject of the connections between Secular and Haredi women and how by bringing these women together, it represents the meaning of being a Jewish Woman in South Africa.The evening was also a great opportunity to show the South African Jewish Community how these women from Israel managed their complex relationships within a diverse religious environment, and further how this can be applied to any conflict situation. These women realised that although they had some different religious beliefs, at the end of the day they actually had so much in common, that this enriched their lives, ultimately leading them to become true friends. Great project that hopefully will be established in South Africa.Link to the movie: http://goo.gl/8LlPEsShabbat Shalom. Rabbi Julia MargolisPicture: Estee Stern, Adina Roth, Rabbi Margolis, Marlene Bethlehem, Gila Joffee and Hila Timor Ashur

  • Parashat Ekev

    Deuteronomy 7.12 – 11.25 Haftarah: Isaiah 49:14-51:3Rabbi SchellParashat Ekev continues the speeches of Moses to the Israelites. He tells them, if they maintain their covenant with God by observing all the commandments, God will make them fruitful and victorious over their enemies. Reminding them of their 40 years of wandering in the wilderness, Moses tells them: “God subjected you to the hardship of hunger … then gave your manna … in order to teach you that human beings do not live on bread alone.“ He then wants them that after settling in the land and enjoying its fruits, they should not arrogantly assume: “My own power and the might of my own hand have one this wealth for me.” Nor, continues Moses, should they conclude that it is for their virtue that God allows them to defeat their enemies and conquered their land. Rather, it is punishment of the inhabitants for idolatry, and it is god’s fulfilment of the covenant made with Abraham Isaac and Jacob.Moses raises important ethical considerations in this speech. Recalling the difficult years of wandering through the desert, he tells them that God has tested them with hunger, long days of hot sun, and long cold nights. The years were filled with harsh trials. Moses, however, does not focus only on the past. He worries about the future. He foresees a time when the Israelites will be comfortable, prosperous, and secure in the land.  They will have defeated their enemies and will be enjoying flourishing economy.  He wonders what the state of being spiritual health will be in such a future time of victory and abundance.Modern commentator Nachama Leibowitz points out that Moses’ observations focus on the tendency of human arrogance and the resulting danger in forgetting human reliance upon God.  In blindness, she writes, human beings tend to detect the guiding hand of God only when it is visible in miracles.  They fail to see the hidden miracles performed for them continually, even when the world around them … seems to be going on as usual.  Moses’s words are against such blindness.Nearly all the commentators of Moses words see in them a significant lesson. They single out arrogance and pride is dangers that lead to moral insensitivity, corruption, and the denial of God.Moses is suggesting that the anti-dot for arrogance is both gratitude and the power of recollection.  Rabbis have extended his view, concluding that the appreciation of history puts all human accomplishments into perspective. It roots us in gratitude and a sense of obligation for the gifts of God.                                                               – Rabbi Adrian M Schell (Source: Harvey Fields, Torah commentary)Podcast of Rabbi Schell’s Radio Sermons on Radio Today, follow http://betdavid.podomatic.com/.

  • May Shira’s memory be for a blessing

    R Margolis 1This past week has been a dark one in Israel. We are all mourning the innocent children murdered in the name of baseless hatred. There is no justification to any murder. It’s a loss of life, doesn’t matter how old is the human being, but the situation becomes impossible for understanding when we are talking about a 16th year old girl who was murdered before she was able to start her life. One of my dear friends is Rabbi Stephen Fuchs, he is the former president of the World Union for Progressive Judaism. Rabbi Fuchs is trying to look at this horror from a different angle, he shared with me his thoughts about Shira’s death and allowed me to share with our congregants.No country in Asia comes close to Israel’s affirmation of LGBT rights, and observers commonly regard Tel Aviv as one of he most gay-friendly cities in the world. The government of Israel affirms LGBT rights, and even the mainstream Orthodox establishment concurs. When the chief rabbi of Jerusalem, Aryeh Stern, went to Hadassah Ein Kerem Hospital to visit the victims of Yishai Schlissel’s despicable stabbings at the annual Gay Pride parade, he proclaimed, “It is a day to pray for the safety of the wounded.”His visit was an important gesture and sent an important message. The Orthodox establishment is not the problem. In fairness too, far from all the ultra-Orthodox population advocate violence against Israel’s LGBT population.And yet we cannot deny that Yishai Schlissel comes from a fanatical fringe environment that continually calls any sort of LGBT sexual activity an “abomination.” An apt analogy is Yigal Amir’s 1995 assassination of Yitzhak Rabin. Most of Israel supported Rabin, but many citizens objected to his peace initiative. Supporters and detractors engaged in vigorous debate, but only the fringe far right called him a rodef, one who threatened Jewish lives and was therefore fair game to be cut down. That fringe right — well beyond the Orthodox and even much of the ultra-Orthodox spectrum — also influenced Yishai Schlissel. He took cues from the likes of chief rabbi of the Samaria region in the West Bank, Elyakim Levanon, who called homosexuality “an abomination.”Ah, the old abomination tag? It comes from Leviticus 18:22, which calls men lying with men an abomination, and 20:13, which says those who do so “shall be put to death.” As many have pointed out, if we did that, those who gather sticks on the Shabbat or insult their parents are also subject to execution. The real sin here is “bibliolatry” the sin of taking the Bible literally and not interpreting it to reflect anything beyond the literal rendering of the words. What gives homosexual acts “privilege of place” over those other “abominations”?Here’s a guess. Everyone gets that the death for gathering sticks on Shabbat business is to impress the reader with the importance of making Shabbat a special time. The same goes for impressing kids to respect their folks. As for a man lying with a man, we need a different perspective. I challenge anyone to carefully read the 39 books of the Hebrew Bible and show me a single clear reference to a homosexual relationship described in warm, loving terms. David’s relationship with Jonathan might have been that (I Samuel, 19 ff) or it could have been a strong “bromance.” We cannot be sure. What is sure is that the only clear biblical references to men “lying with men” are to forced acts of homosexual sex as in the context of war or rape situations. The desire of the men of Sodom to force themselves upon Lot’s protected guests (Genesis 19) is a prime example. Of course the Bible condemns such acts. It is clear to me as well that the “abomination” passages are trumped by one of the most basic principles of Hebrew thought: that human beings are created “in the image of God (Genesis 1:26ff).”Any serious Bible student should be able to see that if God made people a certain way, and we revere God, than we need to respect the diverse innate realities of others’ lives as a reflection of the Divine. The ability to interpret biblical passages as I do here (and the way I do so in my book What’s in It for Me? Finding Ourselves in Biblical Narratives) is not new. In the Talmudic era (c. 200 B.C.E. until c. 550 C.E.) wise sages interpreted scripture in such a way to upgrade the status of women in many important ways and made other vital innovations to bring the emerging Jewish religion from an ancient agrarian society to a much more urban one. Unfortunately, the fringe ultra-Orthodox has failed to evolve in any way since then. As far as LGBT issues go, society itself has been slow to evolve. The good news is that we are in a period of great awakening and growing awareness. Let’s pray and hope that this horrible experience we saw this past week will never comeback. May Shira’s memory be for a blessing. –  Rabbi Julia Margolis

  • Bet David condemns the acts of unjustified violence and hatred in Jerusalem.

    Comfort. Comfort and There is No ComfortIn the course of the last few hours two hate crimes have taken place in Israel, our Jewish Homeland. In the first, a man previously convicted of stabbing participants in a Gay Pride event has done it again, with the result of six injuries, some of them grave. In the second case, two men entered a home in a Palestinian village near Nablus, set fire to the inhabitants (one baby lies dead, and three family members are fighting for their lives) and sprayed the Hebrew word nekamah – revenge. It is reasonable to assume that the perpetrators were responding to the decision of the Supreme Court that property occupied by Jewish settlers had to be destroyed because it was built on private Palestinian land. The South African Association of Progressive Rabbis condemns these acts of unjustified violence and hatred.This is meant to be the Sabbath of nechamah, comfort, which comes after the Ninth of Av in our liturgical calendar. It is meant to offer hope that even after gazing into the pit of destruction, some glimmer of hope may be found. And yet this Sabbath has been turned from a celebration of nechamah, a reflection on the healing powers of recovery, to one in which the dreadful price of nekamah, the dynamics of vengeance, are playing out in front of our eyes.Destruction and then comfort – that is meant to be the narrative. Instead, we are faced with the chilling prospect of a cycle which leads from destruction to self-destruction; from mourning to arson; from inconsolable loss to uncontrollable hatred.What are people of conscience to do in the face of unconscionable acts? How are we meant to respond to acts of depravity aimed to deflect us from the arc of redemption towards the spiral of vendetta? We don’t know if anything we do can hold back the momentum of murder. Extremists always trump moderates. But we do know that if there is any meaning to being part of the Jewish people, it is expressed by facing up and taking responsibility.There is a symbolic aspect to this – we will have to express solidarity with victims in ways we may have shied away from in the past. The current situation may test our sense of who is on “our side”.Along with expressions of solidarity, we believe we also have to delve into the ideology and identity which gives the stabbers and the burners a sense of legitimacy, a license to kill. Can we express and exemplify a Judaism of love and of life, one rooted in humanity and moderation?The prospects for Israeli society are bleeding and charred this Shabbat. If we are to turn the perversity of nekamah into the possibility of nechamah, we will need to forge new alliances, find new resources, and refuse to abandon the arc of redemption. Can a Torah of reasonableness overcome an ideology of insanity? We should stake our lives on that proposition. Rabbi Adrian Michael Schellon behalf of the rabbis of the South African Association of Progressive Rabbis(This statement is based on a response by Rabbi Michael Marmur, PHD,Hebrew Union College-Jewish Institute of Religion, Jerusalem, Israel)

  • Who‘s afraid of Reform Judaism?

     by Rabbi Gilad KarivRabbi Gilad Kariv is the Executive Director of the Israel Movement for Reform and Progressive JudaismThe US Supreme Court decision to compel all 50 states to recognize the right of gay couples to marry was celebrated as a historic, reality-changing event. To a large extent it was. But anyone familiar with the gay community’s struggle for acceptance, dignity and equality knows it was the culmination of a long and often arduous process. There were two preliminary stages that made the legal and constitutional change possible: First, the evolution of a culture of political correctness in relation to the gay community and the drawing of red lines defining what is and what isn’t acceptable in public discourse. Second, the establishment of facts on the ground, which helped to shape reality and ultimately to create a mass culture in which gay couples have a dignified and respectful place.Something similar is happening with regard to the long march for acceptance of Reform and Conservative Judaism in Israel. The storm of angry reaction in early July to Religious Services Minister David Azoulay’s contention that “Reform Jews aren’t really Jews” reflects a huge shift in what Israeli opinion is prepared to tolerate. The prime minister’s swift condemnation and the fact that he was immediately joined by Orthodox politicians like Education Minister Naftali Bennett and Deputy Foreign Minister Tzipi Hotovely is indicative of a profound change in public sensibilities. The media also slammed Azoulay’s comments and gave the issue high-profile coverage. Obviously the wall-to-wall denunciations did not change the legal position or alter government policy. Reform and Conservative Judaism still face severe legal and institutional discrimination in Israel.Nevertheless, as the gay triumph in the US shows, the pathway to change runs through cumulative shifts in public and government discourse. And here the ultra-Orthodox Shas minister’s rant achieved precisely the opposite of what he intended and made a significant contribution to the red lines in public debate on Reform and Conservative Judaism. Drawing those red lines is important and necessary. But it is clearly not sufficient. The US Supreme Court ruling only came after hundreds of thousands of gays lived as married couples, after innumerable TV series and films showed them in a favorable and sympathetic light, and after countless public campaigns conferred practical recognition. More than creating a new reality, the Supreme Court put its imprimatur on a reality, which already existed outside the courtroom. The non-Orthodox streams in Israel are trying to make their public breakthrough in much the same way. For years their modus operandi had been based on initiating legislative change to facilitate their growth in Israel. Over the past decade that approach has been turned on its head. The current view is that only creation of facts on the ground and the establishment of a significant presence will transform relations between religion and state in way that genuinely includes the non-Orthodox streams, enhancing Israel’s Jewish and democratic character.Over the past decade, this new approach has led to the establishment of scores of new Reform and Conservative communities in Israel, the ordainment of around 100 non-Orthodox Israeli-born rabbis, significant investment in kindergartens and schools, and the development of a wide array of programs for young Israelis. Recent surveys by leading polling institutions show that eight percent of the Jewish public in Israel define themselves as Reform or Conservative (as compared to 26 percent Orthodox). As many as a third of the Jewish public have participated in a ceremony, prayer or lesson led by a Reform or Conservative rabbi in the past three years. Reform and Conservative education programs have been approved by the Education Ministry, and are taught in Israeli state schools. In dozens of local councils there is fruitful cooperation. True, both movements still encounter glass ceilings. But gradually cracks are beginning to appear.When Azoulay railed against Reform Jews, his attack was not directed primarily at a religious ideology or at the millions of Reform Jews in North America. What bothered him far more were the growing numbers of Israeli Jews who see in Reform or Conservatism the form of Judaism that best suits their religious needs. The promised land of religious pluralism in Israel is still a long way off. But one thing is certain. The furor following Azoulay’s outburst proves that Reform and Conservative Judaism in Israel have broken free of their slave chains and begun their journey to freedom and equality. The minister and his colleagues can try chasing after them to bring them back. But, as the book of Exodus shows, it didn’t work then. And it won’t work

  • Parashat Va’etchanan

    -Shema-Israel-DJ-SHMA_largeMoses looks at the Promised Land by the banks of the river Jordan, and continues his final speech to the Israelites before he dies. He pleads with God to allow him to enter the Land of Israel, but he is refused. Once again Moses stresses to the Israelites the importance of keeping God’s commandments when they enter the land of Israel; repeats the “Ten Commandments” and utters the Shema and Ve-ahavta. Finally, Moses informs the Israelites that they are God’s chosen and treasured people who will be loved by God if they remain loyal to God’s covenant.The Shema may not be the most important prayer in our liturgy, but it is certainly amongst the contenders, and for many people it is the prayer which they always remember. Taken from the Torah, the first paragraph (less the second line – baruch shem kevod malchuto leolam va’ed) appears as part of this week’s portion. While we often focus on the words and meaning of the Shema it is interesting to look at it in its original context, outside of the service and in our Torah.There it appears in relation to the Promised Land, and “our” well-being in the land, after we have entered it. But on a symbolic level it represents a quest for a place of promise, aspiration and hope. In this way the Promised Land represents an idealised situation for which we strive rather than a specific geographic location, and in this regard the Shema may therefore be seen as a five-point blueprint for reaching the Promised Land.The first requirement of the Shema is to love God, we need to be in a relationship with something greater than ourselves. This is then followed by the need for education, teaching the next generation, our children. And no opportunity for education should ever be missed, when we’re sitting in our homes, walking on the streets, lying down or rising up – all of them are opportunities. Then these values must be taken and made a part of our very being, bound to our heads as the place of thought and our arms as the place of action. Finally we need to make these values a part of the homes which we build, inscribing them on our doors and at our gates.Seen in this light the Shema is not just a piece of Torah, not just a prayer in our liturgy, it is also an action plan for how we might achieve the Promised Land today.                                                               – Rabbi Adrian M Schell (based on a text from Rabbi Danny Burkeman)Torah Reading for Shabbat NachamuParashat Va’etchanan: Deuteronomy 3:23-7:11Haftarah: Isaiah 40:1-26Podcast of Rabbi Schell’s Radio Sermons on Radio Today, follow http://betdavid.podomatic.com/. 

  • Tischa beAw: Nähe zu Gott – auch ohne Tempel

    Tischa beAw – Ein zentrales Heiligtum ist für den Bund mit dem Ewigen nicht nötig. Wir können ihm an jedem Ort der Welt begegnen …Mein Artikel in der Jüdischen Allgemeinen zum Nachlesen:http://www.juedische-allgemeine.de/article/view/id/228472015-07-23 17.41.35

  • Parashat Mattot Masei: We cannot feign ignorance to these humanitarian crises.

    The obligation to protect human life, stands at the centre of our tradition. Derived from a verse in Leviticus which reads, “Neither shall you stand by the blood of your neighbor,” the classical rabbis developed the overarching principle of pikuach nefesh, which asserts the supreme responsibility of protecting individuals who are in potentially life-threatening situations.This week’s parashah includes a distinctive Torah instruction which reflects our tradition’s view to protection life and, in particular, of those people in society who are vulnerable. The Israelites are instructed upon entering the land of Canaan to designate arei miklat, cities of refuge, which would function as asylums for the perpetrators of unintentional manslaughter from violent retribution by their victims’ relatives.As we read the Torah’s instructions we are reminded of the huge number of refugees and displaced persons currently scattered across South Africa and around the globe.When it comes to dealing with the reality of displaced people, the biblical institution of cities of refuge provide us with a Jewish foundation for pro-action.In the Talmud, the cities of refuge are discussed in a number of places. In tractate Baba Batra of the Talmud we find a striking teaching within a seemingly mundane legal discussion concerning the proper width of a variety of pathways: “Our Rabbis taught: A private path is of the width of four cubits; a path from one town to another is to have a width of eight cubits; a public road, 16 cubits; the road to the cities of refuge, 32 cubits.”What is noteworthy about this teaching is that we find that the road to a city of refuge was required to be twice as wide as an ordinary public road. These teachings reflect something remarkable about the rabbinic attitude toward cities of refuge. The emphasis on the great width and sound condition of the roads leading to cities of refuge, illustrates the seriousness, with which the rabbis approached this biblically mandated communal responsibility.If our tradition displays such concern for people who have themselves committed murder, even if unintentionally, how much more so should we feel compelled to protect these tens of millions of refugees, the bulk of whom are not themselves criminals but rather innocent bystanders driven from their homes as a result of wars and violence.Living in a time where foreigners are exposed to hate and prosecution, we cannot feign ignorance to these humanitarian crises, regardless of where they may be occurring. And armed with the knowledge of these emergencies, we are faced, as individuals, communities, and as nations, with the choice of whether or not to respond.There are many things that we can do. We can support the important work of organizations like UNICEF to lower the pain of refuges over the world, we can support Keren b’Kavod in Israel, the progressive Aid organization in Israel, or our local Jewish and Christian organization that are here to help. We can raise awareness in our Jewish communities of the refugee crisis.As is often noted, the Torah has more to say about the proper treatment of strangers than it does with any other set of laws, including worshipping God or observing festivals.Today is Mandela Day, and perhaps we all can contribute to the ideas and dreams he envisioned for South Africa, a State where the human dignity of every individual is the highest treasure we have.Shabbat Shalom(Source: Rabbi Danny Burkeman)